All 38 cases

Evaluation case pol-05, from the policy suite

What's the rule on health inspections?

Run 1 passRun 2 fail

Asked as Mekong Noodle Housenot-covered

What should happen

Answered without citing anything, because no section of this restaurant's policies applies.

What the trace shows

At 0.50 nothing scored above the line and the model said the policies do not cover health inspections. At 0.40 the Allergies section scored 0.41 and was shown. The model still said the policies do not cover it, and cited the section to say it does not apply. My grader's rule for a not-covered case is that nothing is shown and nothing is cited, so this counts as a fail. The answer is right. The grade is the price of the lower threshold, and the rule is mine to reconsider.

Each run

Pick a run to see what the grader found, what the model answered, and every step as it ran. Steps marked model were decided by Claude; steps marked code ran as fixed logic; a person appears only where someone approved or rejected something.

What the grader found in run 2

  • retrieval returned sections above threshold: ['House Policy §7, Allergies']
  • cited ['House Policy §7, Allergies'] although nothing should apply

What it answered

The policies don't cover health inspections. The only nearby section is about allergies, and it says nothing on inspections. says an order noting a nut, shellfish, or gluten allergy is made by the lead cook and checked by a manager before it leaves the kitchen. It also says the restaurant doesn't guarantee any dish is free of those allergens, and staff must say so when asked. For inspection rules, check your local health department's requirements or any document that isn't loaded here.

answered

  • $0.0041to answer, $0.0154 without the prompt cache
  • 3.5 s3.1 s in the model
  • 4steps, 6,615 tokens in, 213 out
  1. Human

    Asked

    What's the rule on health inspections?

  2. Model

    Looked up the policy

    “health inspections rule”

    3,222 tokens in (3,121 from cache), 51 out

  3. Code

    Retrieved 1 section

    Searched this restaurant's policies only. Threshold 0.4; the model saw only the sections above it.

    • 0.41 House Policy §7, Allergies
    • 0.34 House Policy §1, Scope and Authority (below threshold)
    • 0.33 House Policy §5, Staff Meals (below threshold)
    • 0.32 House Policy §2, Comps (below threshold)
  4. Model

    Answered

    The policies don't cover health inspections. The only nearby section is about allergies, and it says nothing on inspections. says an order noting a nut, shellfish, or gluten allergy is made by the lead cook and checked by a manager before it leaves the kitchen. It also says the restaurant doesn't guarantee any dish is free of those allergens, and staff must say so when asked. For inspection rules, check your local health department's requirements or any document that isn't loaded here.

    3,393 tokens in (3,121 from cache), 162 out

  5. Code

    Citations checked

    Every section cited was one that was retrieved: House Policy §7, Allergies.

answered

  • $0.0041to answer, $0.0154 without the prompt cache
  • 3.5 s3.1 s in the model
  • 4steps, 6,615 tokens in, 213 out